Book Review: It Started With A Sperm

Publication date:  January 2019book

Review, short version:  Two roses out of four.

Review, long version:

Sperm donation.

It seems an odd way to start talking about a book, but on one level, that’s what it’s about.

A healthy man in his mid-20s goes to a sperm bank.  He’s screened and if deemed acceptable, makes the decision regarding keeping his identity anonymous, or not.

He ejaculates and gets a little pleasure, a little money, leaves and forgets about it.  He may do this more than once, leaving behind millions of sperm each time.

Sil children_01If the man’s sperm is used, he may become the biological father of one, 10, 50 or more children – a 2011 New York Times article cited a donor with 150+ offspring.

Most donors never know how many children are born with their sperm, and if those children discover the donor’s identity, he may or may not choose to connect with them.  The children may or may not discover their half-siblings.

One of those sperm donor children – conceived in the mid-1960s – was Dani Shapiro, author of Inheritance:  A Memoir of Genealogy, Paternity and Love.

At first, being a sperm donor offspring wasn’t part of the equation; all Dani knew was that the man she called “Father” was not her biological father.Sperm

She didn’t learn this until she was 54 years old.

I couldn’t empathize with Shapiro, but I could sympathize with her.  She does a good job telling her story in a way that I was with her, step by step, steps backward and steps forward.

From the shock of an DNA test – done more on a whim than any real curiosity about her history – along the often-painful path of trying to learn who she was and make some kind of sense of it.

Did her mother have an affair?  Did her parents use a sperm donor?  Why did they keep it a secret?  Who was her biological father?  Was he still alive?  Would he want to know about her?  Would he want to know her? 

Shapiro’s discovery split her life into Before and After like an earthquake splits a two-earthquake_03lane highway into two halves.  But a road can be put back as it was; Shapiro’s life could not.

One aspect I liked about Inheritance was Shapiro’s skillful use of similes and metaphors.  After her discovery, the relatives she’d cherished all her life…

“…floated away from me like dozens of life rafts.”

“Our educated guesses had propelled the ride up – but we had no idea what would happen once we hurtled into the wild speed just on the other side of the crest.”

“He had the potential to be an arrow, pulled back tightly in its bow, aimed straight and true.

“I am the black box, discovered years – many years – after the crash.”

While struggling across the minefield of lies and secrets in her own history, Shapiro was also learning more about the process of sperm donation and about others who, like her, “felt exiled from their own identities, set apart by a lack of information.”

That included meeting with Cappy Rothman, M.D., co-founder of California Cryobank, cryobankthe world’s largest sperm bank.  One of the striking aspects of this meeting was Rothman’s complete lack of understanding about the possible – probable – trauma experienced by people making the same discovery that Shapiro did.

Shapiro:  “It can be very traumatic.  To not know.  And then to find out.”

“Why is it traumatic?”  Rothman looked puzzled.  “You’re here, aren’t you?”

Clearly Rothman and others in his business are more interested in making babies – and money – than pondering the unintended consequences of what they’re doing.

No exact numbers are known, but it is known that thousands of babies are conceived through sperm donations every year.Unintended-Consequences-720-480

That’s a lot of unintended consequences ahead.

Such as unknowingly marrying a half-sibling.

So Inheritance is part social commentary.  But it’s also part mystery, part detective story, part tragedy and part…

OK:  No spoilers.

Read it.

And then think about it, too.

Apparently California Cryobank has a line of other products besides sperm.  This collection is called spermabilia.
Cryobank magnet_02


cryobank cards cropped Cryobank t-shirt
Cryobank tote bag Cryobank statue Cryobank item_01
Cryobank magnets_01 Cryobank t shirt Cryobank magnet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: